Startup Litigation – Morley or Sherlock’s Moriarity – The Strange Case of Morley v Square, Inc.

Have to love a United States District Court complaint that starts as follows:

“The publicized origin story of Square, Inc. is a fabrication. The business now known as Square was not created solely by Jack Dorsey and James McKelvey. It was Professor Robert Morley— and Dr. Morley alone— who invented the Square card reader, and Dr. Morley coinvented the corresponding magnetic stripe decoding algorithms of the Square app. Dr. Morley had over a decade of experience in the credit card industry, spanning card reader technology,
industry contacts, and business operations. In contrast, Messrs. Dorsey and McKelvey had no noteworthy experience in the credit card industry. Dorsey, Morley, and McKelvey worked together in a joint venture with the goal of entering the mobile credit card transaction industry inventing the Square card reader, which enabled Square’s entry into the mobile credit card transaction industry, Dr. Morley contributed his technological expertise and knowledge of the credit card industry to the joint venture. But Messrs. Dorsey and McKelvey betrayed the joint venture by incorporating Square, Inc., dictating the ownership of the newly incorporated company, and cutting Dr. Morley completely out of the enterprise.And in an attempt to whitewash these transgressions, Square has embroiled Dr. Morley in years of litigation and proceedings before the United States Patent and Trademark Office— forcing him to defend himself against the company he helped create. This lawsuit seeks justice for Dr. Morley, redress and redemption.”

For you startup litigation geeks:

Count One – Breach of Joint Venture Agreement

Count Two – Breach of Fiduciary Duty

Count Three – Unjust Enrichment

Count Four – Patent Infringement

Count Five – Consturctive Trust

Count Six – Civil Conspiracy

Count Seven – Negligent Misrepresentation

Count Eight – Fraud

Count Nine – Fraudulent Nondisclosure

Count Ten – Correction of Inventorship

Count Eleven – Conversion

Count Twelve – Misappropriation of Trade Secrets